Nevear is a leading custom apparel manufacturer
Guides & Advice••7 min read

Screen Printing vs DTG: Cost, Quality and Which to Choose

Screen printing pushes ink through a stencil, one screen per color; DTG prints the design straight onto the garment like an inkjet. How they compare on cost, colors, feel, durability and fabrics, and which one suits your order.

By John Grentner

Black t-shirt printed with large lettering in blended pink, orange and blue gradients

In brief

  • Screen printing uses one stencil (a screen) per color, so setup costs more but each extra print is cheap. It wins on larger orders and designs with few colors.
  • DTG (direct to garment) prints the whole design digitally with no screens, so it suits small runs, photos, gradients and many colors.
  • DTG works best on 100% cotton. Dark garments need a pretreatment and a white ink layer under the colors.
  • The break-even point depends on the number of colors: the more colors, the bigger the order before screen printing becomes cheaper.

How screen printing works

The design is separated into its colors, and each color gets its own screen: a fine mesh with a stencil of that part of the design. Ink, usually plastisol or a water-based ink, is pushed through the screen onto the garment with a squeegee, one color at a time, and then cured with heat.

Making and setting up the screens is the expensive part, and it is paid once per design and color. After that, each print is quick and cheap. Screen printing gives bright, opaque colors, holds up well in the wash, and is the method behind special effects such as puff print, metallic and high-density inks.

How DTG works

DTG (direct to garment) works like an inkjet printer for clothing. The garment is loaded flat and the printer sprays water-based pigment ink into the fabric, so there are no screens and no setup per color. Photos, gradients and designs with dozens of colors cost the same to print as a single color.

DTG ink is made for cotton. On dark garments, a pretreatment liquid is applied and heat-pressed first, and the printer lays down white ink before the colors so they stay bright. That extra step adds time and cost to every dark garment.

Cost per piece: where the lines cross

Cost per print by order size (illustrative)

Screen printing DTG

Pieces in the order

Illustrative: a four-color front print, with $25 setup per color plus $3.00 per print for screen printing, against $7.00 per print for DTG. These are not Nevear prices.
The same example in numbers. Illustrative only: these are not Nevear prices.
PiecesScreen printingDTG
10$13.00$7.00
25$7.00$7.00
50$5.00$7.00
100$4.00$7.00
250$3.40$7.00
500$3.20$7.00

Screen printing spreads its setup across the order, so the price per piece falls fast and then levels off. DTG costs about the same per piece whatever the quantity. Where the lines cross depends on the design: with one or two colors, screen printing becomes cheaper at a smaller order; with many colors, or a dark garment for DTG, the crossing point moves. It is the same logic as minimum order quantities, explained in our MOQ guide.

Screen printing vs DTG side by side

How the two methods compare.
Screen printingDTG
SetupA screen per colorNone
Best order sizeLarger runs of one designOne-offs and small runs
ColorsEach color adds a screenUnlimited, including gradients and photos
FeelInk sits on the fabric; plastisol can feel thickerInk soaks into the fabric; soft on light garments
DurabilityVery durable when properly curedGood when pretreated and cured correctly
FabricsCotton, blends and polyester with the right inkBest on 100% cotton
Dark garmentsOpaque ink covers wellNeeds pretreatment and a white ink layer
Special effectsPuff, metallic, high density and moreFlat prints only
Navy t-shirt with bold white lettering laid flat on wooden boards next to sneakers and jeans
A one-color design like this is where screen printing is cheapest at volume. A multi-color gradient like the one at the top of this page is easier with DTG on a small run.

What about DTF?

DTF (direct to film) is a third option. The design is printed onto a film with a white layer behind the colors, coated with an adhesive powder and then heat-pressed onto the garment. Like DTG it needs no screens, but it works on cotton, polyester and blends, which makes it useful for small runs on mixed fabrics. The print sits on top of the fabric as a thin, flexible layer, so it feels less soft than DTG on cotton.

Which should you choose?

  • 50 or more pieces of one design in a few solid colors: screen printing.
  • A photo, gradient or many colors on a small run: DTG on cotton.
  • Many designs with only a few pieces each: DTG, or DTF on mixed fabrics.
  • Polyester or performance fabrics: screen printing with suitable ink, DTF, or sublimation on light polyester.
  • A raised effect: screen printing with puff ink.

At Nevear the minimum is typically 50 pieces per item, and we confirm the print method that suits your design and quantity in your quote. Samples take 2–3 weeks, and bulk orders usually arrive 3–4 weeks from the order date, shipping included. See our t-shirt and hoodie pages for the garments.

Frequently asked questions

Is screen printing or DTG better quality?

It depends on the design. Screen printing gives the brightest, most opaque solid colors and the widest choice of inks; DTG reproduces photos, gradients and fine color detail without extra cost.

Which lasts longer?

A properly cured screen print is the most durable option. DTG prints hold up well when the garment is pretreated and cured correctly and washed inside out.

Can you screen print a photo?

Yes, using halftones, where tiny dots in a few ink colors build up the image. It works, but DTG reproduces photos and gradients more easily, especially on small runs.

Does DTG work on polyester?

DTG inks are made for cotton, so results on polyester are less reliable. For polyester, DTF, sublimation (on light colors) or screen printing with suitable ink are usually better choices.

What is the minimum order at Nevear?

Typically 50 pieces per item. The exact minimum depends on the garment and print method, and is confirmed in your quote.

Not sure which print method suits your design?

Send your artwork, garment and quantities, and we will recommend a method and confirm the price per piece.

Ask us

More Manufacturing Guides & Insights

Ready to Start Your Next Apparel Collection?

Nevear helps brands move from idea to finished product with custom apparel manufacturing, private label clothing production, quality control, packaging, and global logistics. Whether you are launching a new collection or scaling bulk apparel production, we are ready to support your next step.

Get a Custom Apparel Quote